| Batting Categories | Reds | Mets | |||
| Batting Average (400 PA) | Votto | .337 | Murphy | .291 | REDS |
| Hits | Phillips | 163 | Duda | 96 | REDS |
| Home Runs | Bruce | 34 | Davis | 32 | REDS |
| RBI’s | Votto | 56 | Wright | 93 | METS |
| Stolen Bases | Stubbs | 30 | Tejada | 4 | REDS |
| Pitching Categories | |||||
| Innings Pitched | Cueto | 217 | Pelfrey | 19.2 | REDS |
| Wins | Leake | 8 | Nies | 13 | METS |
| ERA (min 180 IP) | Cueto | 2.78 | Santana | DNQ | REDS |
| Strikeouts | Latos | 185 | Nies | 155 | REDS |
| Saves | Marshall | 13 | Rodriguez | 0 | REDS |
| Team Categories | |||||
| Head to Head | 6 | 2 | REDS | ||
| Team Wins | 97 | 74 | REDS | ||
| Higher Divisional Standing | 1st | 4th | REDS | ||
| Most Inter-league Wins | 7 | 8 | METS | ||
| Most Players on All-Star Team | 3 | 2 | REDS |