| Batting Categories | Reds | Results | Mets | Results | Winner |
| Batting Average (400 PA) | Votto | .323 | Wright | .283 | Reds |
| Hits | Phillips | 172 | Wright | 166 | Reds |
| Home Runs | Bruce | 25 | Bay | 6 | Reds |
| RBI’s | Votto | 112 | Bay | 47 | Reds |
| Stolen Bases | Stubbs | 30 | Reyes | 30 | Tie |
| Pitching Categories | |||||
| Innings Pitched | Harang | 111.2 | Pelfrey | 204 | Mets |
| Wins | Cuerto | 12 | Santana | 11 | Reds |
| ERA (min 180 IP) | Cuerto | 3.64 | Santana | 2.98 | Mets |
| Strikeouts | Bailey | 100 | Santana | 144 | Mets |
| Saves | Cordero | 40 | Rodriguez | 25 | Reds |
| Team Categories | |||||
| Head to Head | 4-2 | 2-4 | Reds | ||
| Team Wins | 91 | 79 | Reds | ||
| Higher Divisional Standing | First | Fourth | Reds | ||
| Most Inter-league Wins | 8 | 13 | Mets | ||
| Most Players on All-Star Team | 3 | 1 | Reds | ||
| Total | 10 | 4 |