| Batting Categories | Reds Player | Final Points | Mets Player | Final Points | Winner |
| Batting Average (min of 400 PA) | Casey | .261 | Alomar | .266 | Mets |
| Hits | Casey | 111 | Alomar | 157 | Mets |
| Home Runs | Dunn | 26 | Piazza | 33 | Mets |
| RBI’s | Griffey | 23 | Burnitz | 54 | Mets |
| Stolen Bases | Larkin | 13 | Cedeno | 25 | Mets |
| Pitching Categories | Reds Player | Mets Player | Winner | ||
| Wins | Dessens | 7 | Leiter | 13 | Mets |
| ERA | Hamilton | 5.27 | Leiter | 3.48 | Mets |
| Strikeouts | Dessens | 93 | Leiter | 172 | Mets |
| Complete Games | Hamilton | 0 | Estes | 1 | Mets |
| Saves | Graves | 32 | Benetiz | 33 | Mets |
| Team Categories | |||||
| Head to Head | Mets 4-2 | ||||
| Team Wins | Reds 78-75 | ||||
| Highest Divisional Standing | Reds 3rd Mets 5th | ||||
| Most Inter-league Wins | Reds 2-10 Mets 10-8 | ||||
| Most Players on All-Star Team | Tied – 1 each |